Update: Laura spoke with FleetOwner about the new status of CSA scores and SMS data.

For all its faults, CSA provided context about violation data. Fleets were rated in a peer group of similar-size fleets, and given a percentile ranking. But with the budget deal in Congress worked out over the holidays, the CSA scores were taken away from the public view.

Drinking from a Firehose of Data

Today, the FMCSA announced it would return the underlying data — the Safety Management System (SMS) — to public view. Now that the FMCSA is opening the floodgates to all the violation data, there's no good way to know if, say, 400 HOS violations in a 12 month period is good, bad, or ugly. Moreover, all the data is out there, including crash data and hazmat data.


Wait, is this good or bad? Wait, is this good or bad?


“Be Careful What You Wish For”

From a political standpoint, the FMCSA seems to be escalating the argument with the trucking industry over CSA scores. The CSA scores certainly weren’t perfect, but it’s as if they’re asking, "Now that all the data is out there, how do you feel about CSA scores?"

CSA Scores Shouldn’t Be the Reason You Train

To be blunt, a good safety and training professional shouldn’t worry about CSA scores anyway. For one, CSA scores are a lagging metric: they reflect what’s already happened. But more importantly, they’re an enforcement tool designed to catch and shame "bad actors" — the poor performing fleets.

What we know from best performing fleets is that they try to nip safety problems in the bud. That means looking for leading metrics:  data and trends that can point you to a small problem before it blooms a big problem.

Safety is a Leading Indicator of Profitability

And speaking of leading indicators, safe fleets and well-trained fleets precede profitability. Safe fleets build a culture where drivers take their time, have “soft feet” on the accelerator and brakes, and make HOS recording and pre-trip inspections a part of their routine. That leads to lower fuel costs, longer equipment replacement cycles, lower insurance costs, and fewer liability lawsuits.


Subscribe To Our Blog

Posts by Topic

See More
New call-to-action

You may also like:

Cut Hiring Lawsuits by Educating Drivers on the Drug and Alcohol Clearinghouse

There are many ways the Drug and Alcohol Clearinghouse (DAC) will impact your hiring process. Among them: it’s critical ...

4 Reasons You Need to Think about Fleet Manager Training

How many times have we heard that an employee doesn't leave a company, he leaves his manager? Training improves manager ...

TCA Safety Conference Recap

A few of us ventured to the heart of BBQ country for the TCA Safety and Security conference. This is one of our favorite...